Earth In Crisis: The Damage Done
Suncor vs Boulder: Should Oil & Gas Pay For Destruction Caused By Climate Change?
By Tracey MacDermott | For the GPHN

Autumn colors have been bursting their glory across our city, but Colorado remains in extreme drought. Temperatures were in the 80’s through mid-October and … our neighbors in Boulder continue their landmark case against Suncor Energy.
On Oct. 5, the U.S Supreme Court heard oral arguments in Suncor Energy vs Boulder County Board of Commissioners. In a nutshell, Boulder is asserting that Suncor and Exxon Mobil knowingly lied about the dangers of burning fossil fuels and should be held financially liable for damages brought on by the ensuing changes to our climate, including floods, wildfires and drought.
Here are some basic facts, as highlighted on Boulder County’s website:
• According to the United Nations, burning fossil fuels accounted for nearly 80 percent of all greenhouse gas emissions between 1970 and 2010.
• Exxon is the largest investor-owned producer of fossil fuels in the world.
• Suncor, headquartered in Canada, is one of the world’s largest independent energy companies.
• Both are active in Colorado. Suncor’s U.S. regional headquarters is based in Denver, with a major refinery complex in Commerce City, north of Park Hill. (The company supplies about 35 percent of the state’s gasoline and diesel fuel.)
• Suncor and Exxon work closely together in Colorado to market and sell fossil fuels.
• Suncor and Exxon are responsible for billions of tons of greenhouse gas emissions.
As early as the 1950’s, physicist Edward Teller warned oil executives, in a keynote speech at the American Petroleum Institute, that the burning of fossil fuels and consequent buildup of greenhouse gas emissions could heat the planet and cause the drastic changes to climate that we are now beginning to experience.
In the 1970s, as indicated by internal documents, oil companies acknowledged that fossil fuels would raise global temperatures and potentially lead to severe environmental damage worldwide.
Through the 1980s, the oil industry’s internal documents continued to warn of likelihood and adverse consequences of global warming; however, those warnings were not shared with the public.
Flash forward to Suncor Energy vs Boulder County Board of Commissioners. During oral arguments, not surprisingly, many of the conservative justices did not appear convinced by Boulder’s legal position. Boulder’s case is based on Colorado tort law. Lawyers for the Trump administration and oil companies argued that existing federal laws such as the Clean Air Act — “preempt” state law and therefore block Boulder’s case from proceeding.
The Court will not release its opinion for several months. In the meantime, we, the public, must speak out against the oil companies’ ongoing cover-up of the causes of climate change and the damage it brings.
No matter the outcome of Suncor Energy vs Boulder County Board of Commissioners, all of us should call on our elected officials to hold the oil and gas industry accountable — and yes, pay for the damage its leaders have known for decades was happening.
As they continue to drill, the best thing each of us can do is to wean ourselves off fossil fuels and embrace a clean energy future.
Tracey MacDermott is chair of Greater Park Hill Community, Inc. She was trained as a Climate Reality Leader in 2017. She also chairs the Sustainability Committee for the Business and Professional Women of Colorado and the National Federation for Business and Professional Women. Email her at traceymacdermott@gmail.com
